Trouble: Soap Batter Going Pink

by Carole Bell
(Centennial, Colorado)

I've been making soap for about three years and until recently did not have any problems.

The recipe I have is as follows: 32 oz Olive oil - 24 oz vegetable oil/fat (crisco), 30 oz coconut oil - 32oz distilled water and 12oz lye.
I mixed the lye with the oils when both were 98 dgrees.

My last two batches took on a pinkish look when I added the lye mixture to the oils mixture, but after mixing the pink went away. But the soap did not take on the normal white look. And in addition I noticed that the soap had a bit of a rough texture, not the normal smooth texture, along the cutting edges.

Do you have suggestions as to what I may be doing wrong?


I don't think you are doing anything wrong.

I would look to the ingredients you are using. I'm guessing that one of them is new. Are you using a new package of lye? Perhaps there is a contaminate in it? Or the distilled water contains some sort of mineral? Is it a brand you usually don't purchase? Same goes for the base oils. Are they a different brand than normal? Hopefully Crisco hasn't gone and changed their ingredients again.

The pinkish colour will most likely be a result of a chemical reaction. This isn't something that normally happens with the ingredients you listed in my least not until essential oils or fragrance oils are added.

If all your ingredients are the same as always and not new packages, perhaps the utensils, pots, etc. have not been rinsed properly after washing and contain residue from dish soap or....?

Good luck,

Comments for Trouble: Soap Batter Going Pink

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

I’m pink too! NEW
by: Anonymous

I made the same crisco recipe for the first time and my batter went pink too.. before any fragrance. I fragranced it and divided it into 3 parts, added blue mica to one and pink mica to the other. Left the original color plain ( pale fleshy pink)
Did an in the pot swirl and poured into my loaf mold. It looks pretty for now. We’ll see how it goes. Have never had this with any other recipe before. I thought my utensils, etc were clean ... I am pretty careful and organized. My ingredients are pretty fresh and certainly not out of date. Lye was new and have used with no issue. We’ll see how it turns out but relieved to see this post from someone else! Hope yours is ok too.

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Submit a Question.

Like This Page?