Too much oil?

by Hilde Waterloo
(Leksvik, Norway)


Yesterday I made a new batch of soap, and was SO happy with the end result when I put the lids on the two moulds...

The soap did not come out too good, though.

I used 610 g. coconut oil, 670 g. sunflower oil, 670 g. olive oil, 240 g. lye and 930 ml water/fruit juice mix. Mixed at app. 55 celcius degrees. At trace I added 20 grams of calendula oil, 2 teaspoons of essential oils. I decorated with dried, thin slices of orange. I stacked the two boxes on top of each other and insulated.

Today, the soap is still soft, there was a thin layer of oil (?) on top, and the orange slices were of course soft and wet again... The soap toppings flattened as well.

Have I overfatted too much? Did the soap overheat? Or is it important to heat the overfatting oils (which I did not do)? What about the fruit slices, do you think? Did I spoil my soap?

Thank you for answering :-)


I notice that you have volume measured your water/juice in milliliters rather than weighing it in grams like the rest of the recipe.

When I ran the recipe through SoapCalc, I found that your liquid measure should be around 741 grams or less. Since the mass of 1 milliliter of water equals 1 gram of water, I would say that you have too much liquid in this recipe. Also bear in mind that a milliliter of juice will likely have a different weight than water.

It is important to always weigh the water/juice/milk portion of the recipe as well and to not use volume measures.

I also noticed that your superfat is around 18% - 19% which is quite high.

It's hard to tell if it will be ok or not. You may want to give it a week or so to see if it starts to harden up before deciding to keep it or throw it out.


Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Submit a Question.

Some of the links on this site are affiliate links. If you buy a product through them, I receive a small commission which helps me provide the free information you find on this site. Thank you for your support!

Like This Page?